This one opens with some horseplay at the station. The
detectives are pulling Kling’s leg about receiving a call at the station from
his fiancée. Though it’s no crime to be in love, they make him feel as though
it might be. Regardless, he manages to arrange
their date for later on and he’s particularly excited because of the revelation
about her new bra, teasingly named Abundance.
‘Abundance’ is the final word he hears her say, for the next
time he gets to see Claire, she’ll be the victim of a shooting in a local
bookstore. Steve Carella and Kling take
the call. There are three dead and two wounded. Kling walks into the back of the
shop to see a lady sprawled before him. It slowly dawns on him that she’s
the lady he was having a conversation with in the squad room, the lady who just happened
to be the love of his life.
It’s a hugely charged and emotional moment for the reader.
There’s been an uneasy sense that something is about to go wrong from the off.
For those of us who’ve been reading in order, there’s the double whammy of a
shared history. When we met Kling, we also met Claire. It wasn’t an easy start
for them as a couple, but I was willing them along back then. As Kling falls
apart, he takes us back to those early days and reminds us of their beginnings.
The lump in my throat was big as an ostrich egg.
To balance the sadness, there’s the beauty of the 87th.
The whole squad come together. The file in the office is labelled the Kling
case. Patrolmen and detectives alike rally round, keeping ears open and
focussing on the bookshop murders while everything else takes a back seat. It’s
moving to observe and, because these are old friends rather than just fictional
characters, it’s wonderful to behold.
Carella and Meyer lead this one, but Kling insists on doing
the work. He pulled the call, after all, and has every right to do so. Problem
is, the way the investigation is carried out there’s an assumption that the
killer was after one of the victims. In order to pursue the case, each of them
needs to be investigated in turn and it might be that any guilty secrets in Claire's life will be exposed in the process.
The layers are peeled away with great craft. Each becomes a
story in its own right, though not all of them add anything to the
investigation.
I loved it for many different reasons. It felt personal. The
cops deserve a break. Whatever Claire has been hiding, we know she did it for
the best of reasons. Each set piece is a treat (take Claire's father's reaction as a prime example). By the time we come to the end
of the story, the killer has almost been forgotten, but when the threads are
taken up for one last push, the knots re tied perfectly.
A top-notch crime story that I reckon will have any fan of
fiction hooked.
This one was published
in 1961. Some of the language and terminology reflects that and I find it easy
to get along with it because of the sentiments at its core. I was struck in
this one by a passage about Detective Brown.
Remember that it was almost sixty years ago and then consider what’s
changed.
“He turned on the radio very softly and listened to the news
broadcast as he shaved. Race riots in the Congo. Sit-in demonstrations in the
South. Apartheid in South Africa.
He wondered why he was black.
He often wondered this. He wondered it idly, and with no
real conviction that he was black.
That was the strange part of it. When Arthur Brown looked in the mirror, he saw
only himself. Now he knew he was a Negro, yes. But he was also a Democrat, and
a detective, and a husband, and a father and he read The New York Times – he was a lot of things, and so he wondered why
he was black. He wondered why, being this variety of things besides being
black, people would look at him and see Arthur Brown, Negro – and not Arthur
Brown, detective, or Arthur Brown, husband, or any of the other Arthur Browns
who had nothing to do with the fact that he was black. This was not a simple
concept, and Brown did not equate it in simple Shakespearean-Shylock terms,
which the world had long outgrown.
When Brown looked into the mirror, he saw a person.
It was the world who had decided that this man was a black
man.
Being this person was an extremely
difficult thing, because it meant living a life the world had decided upon, and
not the life he – Arthur Brown – would particularly have chosen. He, Arthur
Brown, did not see a black man or a white man or a yellow man or a chartreuse man when he looked into the mirror.
He saw Arthur Brown.
He saw himself.
But superimposed upon this image of himself was the external
concept of black man-white man, a concept which existed and which Brown was
forced to accept. He became a person playing a complicated role. He looked at
himself and saw Arthur Brown, Man. That’s all he wanted to be. He had no desire
to be white. In fact, he rather liked the warm, burnished colour of his own skin.
He had no desire to go to bed with a creamy-skinned blonde. He had heard
coloured friends of his state that white men had bigger sex organs than
Negroes, but he didn’t believe it, and he felt no envy. He had encountered
prejudice in a hundred and one subtle and unsubtle ways from the moment he was
old enough to understand what was being said and done around him, but the
intolerance never left him feeling angry, it only confused him.
You see, he thought, I am me, Arthur Brown. Now what is all
this white man-black man crap? I don’t understand what you want me to be. You
are saying I’m a Negro, you are telling me this is so, but I don’t know what
Negro means. I don’t know that this whole discussion is all about. What do you
want from me exactly? If I say, why yes, that’s right, I’m a Negro, well then
what? What the hell is it you want? That’s what I’d like to know. Arthur Brown
finished shaving, rinsed his face, and looked into the mirror.
As usual, he saw himself.”
Sixty years ago. My word.
Lady, Lady, I Did It.
Mr McBain, you certainly did.
And if you need another opinion, why not check out Hark the 87th Precinct Podcast here?